When I ran a forward trajectory from a location on a previously computed backward trajectory, I did not return to

Topics about the HYSPLIT trajectory model.
Post Reply
sonny.zinn
Posts: 354
Joined: May 8th, 2019, 1:31 pm
Registered HYSPLIT User: Yes

When I ran a forward trajectory from a location on a previously computed backward trajectory, I did not return to

Post by sonny.zinn »

[Note that the question and the answer below are recreated from a HYSPLIT FAQ site that predates this forum site. The original posting date is unknown.]

Question:
When I ran a forward trajectory from a location on a previously computed backward trajectory, I did not return to the starting location of my backward trajectory. Why?

Answer:
It’s good that you did the backward/forward comparison. Not many users go to the trouble. You discovered the precision/accuracy limitation. Over the integration time interval there is an accumulation of numerical error. It can be reduced by reducing the integration time step but we felt that the current time step gives an acceptable level of precision (about 1% per day) considering the number of users and their typical application. An interesting aspect of a trajectory integration is that as the error accumulates and moves the trajectory into adjacent grid points, the errors can really grow quickly. The numerical uncertainty of your calculation is half of the distance between your return point and start point.

One reason we don’t get too excited about the precision error is that the accuracy is even worse – that may be as high as 5% per day. The trajectory calculation is an integration using discrete data points (gridded values in space and time) to represent a continuous function. How well the gridded data can be used to represent the flow depends upon the size of the flow features and their speed through the domain versus the number of grid points that sample those features. Too coarse data in space and time adds the greatest uncertainty to the calculation.

One test of this would be to rerun your trajectory, but offset the starting point by 0.1 degrees, you will find your endpoint after 10 days to be different by almost 15 deg longitude.

Roland Draxler
Post Reply

Return to “Trajectory Model”